The choice between in-house SEO and outsourcing creates a major financial impact. Building an in-house SEO team costs about $138,040 in the first year. This includes salary, benefits, and overhead expenses. An SEO agency costs less at around $84,000 per year.
Money isn’t the only factor in this decision. SEO agencies bring teams of specialists who work with businesses of all sizes. Building your own team lets you control your SEO strategy directly. Most companies that partner with agencies see better local visibility in 3-6 months. This shows up especially in Google Business Profile rankings and organic traffic. This piece will help you pick the right approach that lines up with your business’s goals, timeline, and budget – whether you want to hire an SEO company or build an internal team.
See how likely ChatGPT and Google’s AI Summaries are to recommend your business’ website compared to your competitors’ websites.
Defining In-House SEO and Outsourcing SEO
The choice between in-house and outsourced SEO boils down to understanding what each option really means. These approaches represent two different ways to handle your search engine optimization strategy. Each comes with its own team structure, costs, and way of doing things.
What does in-house SEO involve?
Your organization manages all SEO activities with its own team members and resources when you choose in-house SEO. You’ll need to hire dedicated SEO professionals who work only for your business. The core team usually has content creators, SEO strategists, technical SEO experts, and link builders who become part of your company structure.
Your internal team takes care of these SEO tasks:
- Planning and carrying out detailed SEO strategies
- Running regular website checks to spot and fix problems
- Researching keywords and analyzing competitors
- Creating and fine-tuning content for search engines
- Keeping track of website performance and analytics
You retain control over execution and strategy with in-house SEO. Your team works right inside your company and gets to know your brand, products, and culture really well. This deep understanding means all SEO work stays true to your brand’s identity and strikes a chord with your target audience.
On top of that, in-house teams combine smoothly with other departments like marketing, content, design, and development. The team can make changes quickly, which helps during critical times like Google updates or when you need immediate fixes.
Building an in-house SEO team costs quite a bit, though. The first-year costs run between $120,000-$140,000+. This includes salaries for specialists, content writers, benefits, SEO tools, and training.
What services do SEO agencies typically offer?
Outsourced SEO means hiring external experts to handle your search engine optimization work. These outside providers could be freelancers, agencies, or specialized companies that focus only on SEO strategies.
Most SEO agencies offer complete service packages that include:
- On-page SEO: Making content, meta tags, page titles, and HTML elements better
- Off-page SEO: Getting quality backlinks and working on external strategies
- Technical SEO: Boosting website speed, mobile-friendliness, and site structure
- Local SEO: Fine-tuning for location-based searches to get local customers
- Content creation and optimization: Developing content that works for SEO
- Keyword research and competitor analysis
- Regular updates and performance tracking
Agency fees typically range from $3,000-$10,000 monthly, but most charge between $250-$750 per month. Some work by the hour ($50-$100) or by project ($1,000-$5,000) based on what you need.
Working with agencies gives you access to specialized knowledge. SEO professionals know all about industry trends, algorithm updates, and what works best in any discipline. They already have expensive SEO tools and tech that would cost a lot to buy yourself.
When does outsourcing SEO make sense?
Several situations make outsourcing the right choice. A tight budget might make outsourcing more cost-effective than keeping an in-house team when you add up tools, content creation, and training costs.
Businesses in competitive fields like finance, health, SaaS, or e-commerce often need agency partnerships. These markets face tough competitors with aggressive SEO strategies that need expert knowledge to match.
Time also plays a big role. Agencies often get results within 3-6 months because they have proven systems in place. Building an in-house team takes 3-6 months just to hire people, plus extra time for training and strategy planning.
Schedule a free consultation with Revved Digital and experience the power of AI-driven SEO services and see how we can transform your online presence and search visibility.
Limited resources make a strong case for outsourcing. Many companies don’t have enough engineering, design, and content staff to support big SEO projects. An agency with detailed tactical support helps you avoid these bottlenecks and speed up your SEO work.
You can focus on your core business while using outside expertise to boost your search visibility and stimulate organic traffic growth.
Budget Breakdown: What You Really Pay For
SEO costs involve much more than just salaries or monthly fees. A clear picture of the budget helps you decide between building your own team or working with an agency.
Salary, benefits, and overhead for in-house SEO
Base salary is just the beginning when you hire in-house SEO talent. An experienced SEO specialist with 5+ years in the field commands between $63,000 and $73,000 annually. SEO managers earn around $86,206 per year.
The real costs are much bigger than the base salary:
- Benefits package: Health insurance, 401(k) matching, and PTO add 30-35% to base salary ($23,800 on a $68,000 salary)
- Overhead costs: Office space, equipment, software, and workspace needs add about 25% ($17,000) to base costs
- Administrative expenses: Accounting, legal fees, liability insurance, and taxes add 18% ($12,240)
- Onboarding investment: New team members need three months of training ($17,000) before they become fully productive
Your first-year cost for one SEO specialist jumps from $68,000 to about $138,040. A full team with specialists, writers, and technical experts can cost between $300,000-$500,000 each year.
Agency pricing models: monthly, hourly, project-based
SEO agencies offer different pricing options that suit various needs:
Monthly retainers are the most popular choice. Small businesses spend $500-$1,500 monthly, while mid-size companies invest $2,000-$5,000 per month. Enterprise-level SEO services start at $3,000-$10,000 monthly.
Hourly rates work best for specific projects or consultations. US-based agencies charge $100-$250 per hour, averaging $125-$175. This option suits audits, one-time optimizations, or supporting in-house teams.
Project-based pricing covers specific tasks like site migrations, content creation, or technical audits. These projects cost between $1,000-$5,000 based on scope. You get budget certainty but might lose some flexibility.
Some agencies mix these approaches or tie costs to performance metrics.
Cost per productive hour: in-house vs agency
Agency rates might seem higher, but they often give you better value for your money.
In-house staff costs cover all 168 monthly working hours, productive or not. The total employment costs ($138,040) divided by actual working hours (minus breaks, vacation, and non-SEO tasks) puts your rate at about $99 per productive hour.
Agency rates run $150-$175 per billable hour. This higher rate saves you money by eliminating:
- Costs of non-productive time
- Tool subscriptions (which can exceed $5,000 monthly for enterprise tools)
- Hiring costs (15-25% of yearly salary per hire)
- Training expenses ($5,000-$10,000 yearly)
Agencies share their costs among many clients. This gives you access to enterprise-level tools and specialized expertise at a fraction of what you’d pay in-house.
Your budget choice depends on what you need. Companies needing constant attention and deep product knowledge might benefit from an in-house team. If you want specialized expertise without the overhead, an agency partnership might be your best bet.
Pros and Cons of Each Approach
Your digital marketing strategy depends on whether you build an internal SEO team or team up with an external agency. The right choice goes beyond just budget – it comes down to what works best for your business operations.
In-house SEO: pros and limitations
Companies find several compelling reasons to build their own SEO team. Internal SEO experts become catalysts for change within organizations. These team members know how to promote SEO priorities across departments, which leads to a company-wide shift toward search-friendly practices.
Your internal teams take complete ownership of SEO processes. This creates a shared sense of achievement that external partners can’t match. The in-house specialists learn everything about your products, audience, and industry. This deep knowledge helps them create individual-specific strategies that match your business goals.
Working together daily brings more benefits. In-house teams collaborate with other departments and encourage creative solutions through regular interactions. Quick access means SEO integrates smoothly into marketing initiatives without delays.
The limitations of in-house SEO are worth noting. The biggest challenge is the expertise gap. Internal teams might not have the wide experience that comes from working with different industries and problems. Complex SEO issues will come up, and your internal specialists might still need outside help. This could cancel out the cost benefits of having in-house talent.
Limited resources create more challenges. Link-building takes lots of time, and companies struggle to justify it as a full-time role. In-house SEO specialists might also fall behind on industry trends and innovation when they work in just one environment.
Agency SEO: advantages and drawbacks
SEO agencies bring strong advantages to the table. They give you access to entire teams of specialists who handle everything from technical optimization to content marketing. This combined expertise helps them solve complex problems with precision that’s hard to match in-house.
Access to technology is another big plus. Agencies invest in premium tools that would cost too much for individual businesses. These resources range from advanced keyword research platforms to sophisticated analytics systems, letting them run better campaigns without extra cost to you.
Flexibility adds another benefit. Agencies can quickly scale their support based on what you need, ramping up or down as your business changes. Growing businesses and those with seasonal demands find this especially helpful.
In stark comparison to this, working with an agency means giving up some control over your SEO efforts. External teams run your strategy on their own, which might leave you less informed about daily activities. Communication can get tricky, especially if your agency works in a different time zone or handles many clients at once.
Brand alignment can be challenging too. External agencies take time to understand your business model, company culture, and target audience. This learning curve might slow down strategy implementation.
Common misconceptions about both
People hold several myths about both in-house and agency SEO. Many think one SEO specialist can do it all in-house. The truth is SEO needs multiple skills – from technical know-how to content creation – rarely found in one person.
Companies often undercount the real cost of in-house SEO. A marketing manager’s base salary (averaging around $67,000 annually) is just the start. You also need to think about health insurance, retirement benefits, vacation time, and equipment. These extras make the total investment much higher.
People often get these things wrong about agency partnerships:
- They expect quick SEO results (but real progress takes months of consistent work)
- They think agencies use generic strategies (but good firms create custom approaches for each business)
- They see SEO as just on-page work (but off-page factors like link building play key roles)
Your specific situation, timeline, and organization will determine which path works best for you.
Tools, Technology, and Reporting Access
Technology access creates the biggest difference between agency and in-house SEO approaches. The tools and reporting capabilities each model uses directly shape how well SEO works. This affects your bottom line through competitive advantages or limitations.
SEO tools agencies provide vs in-house limitations
The SEO software market currently exceeds USD 68.34 billion and keeps growing by double digits. This shows how specialized tools have become vital for search optimization to work. Most agencies subscribe to premium platforms like Ahrefs, Semrush, Moz, and Screaming Frog. A single company would need substantial investment to get these tools independently.
In-house teams must spend USD 3,000 to USD 10,000 per tool annually to access these essential technologies. Working with an agency includes these powerful resources in your service agreement. Your monthly retainer bundles all these expenses together.
The cost benefits aside, agencies use specialized tools for:
- Advanced keyword research and competitor analysis
- Technical SEO audits and crawling capabilities
- Performance tracking across multiple metrics
- Link building and outreach management
- Rank tracking and SERP monitoring
Agencies spread these technology investments across their client base. This creates cost savings that individual businesses cannot match on their own.
Reporting dashboards and performance tracking
SEO dashboards serve as command centers to monitor organic search performance. These visualization tools turn raw search data into applicable information. They connect directly to platforms like Google Search Console and Google Analytics, unlike scattered spreadsheets.
Agency dashboards typically show:
- Organic clicks, impressions, and position rankings
- Keyword performance by page and query
- Technical SEO health indicators
- Backlink profiles and changes
- Conversion data and ROI indicators
Agencies offer customizable white-labeled dashboards that unite these vital KPIs into one interface. This central approach removes manual reporting. Both agencies and clients get immediate views of campaign performance.
In-house teams need substantial investment in dashboard tools or custom development to create similar reporting systems. They also need expertise to set them up correctly.
How tech access impacts SEO outcomes
Evidence-based decision-making drives successful SEO strategies. Immediate analytics help businesses adapt quickly and keep competitive rankings as markets evolve. Organizations without proper tools make decisions based on incomplete information or outdated assumptions.
Advanced SEO analytics tools do more than traditional platforms like GA4 or GSC. They provide AI-driven insights and predictive analysis. These sophisticated options automatically highlight opportunities and risks. SEO professionals spend less time analyzing and more time growing their strategies.
This technology gap leads to different outcomes between agency and in-house approaches. Agencies spot technical issues faster and respond to algorithm changes better. They also take advantage of new opportunities sooner because they have better technology.
Predictive analytics tools help forecast user behavior and market trends. Teams can make strategic adjustments before competitors. This forward-looking ability gives them a clear edge over reactive approaches that limited tool access often forces.
Scenarios: Which Model Fits Your Business Best?
Your specific business scenario determines the right SEO approach. Each business type has unique requirements that might work better with in-house teams, agency partnerships, or a mix of both.
Startups and small businesses with limited budget
Small businesses get the most value from outsourcing their SEO needs. Agency partnerships give you access to expertise without hiring full-time specialists, with economical solutions starting at USD 100 per hour. Local SEO services, which cost around USD 128 per hour, are a great way to get results, especially when you have a business focused on specific geographic areas.
Startups with tight budgets can let agencies handle simple optimizations like Google Business Profile setup, citation building, and local content creation. These elements help nearby customers find your location. Your business might not face tough competition at first, so simple optimization can help you show up in local search results.
Multi-location businesses needing local SEO
Companies with multiple physical locations face unique challenges that need specialized SEO strategies. Research shows all but one of these high-performing multi-location businesses have dedicated local marketing strategies. You’ll need optimized landing pages, Google Business Profile, and hyperlocal content for each location.
A study by Wiideman revealed a 107% boost in rankings by using localized content on location-specific landing pages. Google might flag your pages as duplicate content without this approach and remove them from search results.
Essential strategies include:
- Unique URLs for each location (e.g., mysite.com/locations/sandiego)
- Location-specific keywords and local points of interest
- Consistent NAP (name, address, phone) information across platforms
Enterprises with complex SEO needs
Enterprise organizations usually manage multiple domains, international markets, and various product lines that need coordinated SEO strategies. Enterprise SEO needs sophisticated tools and platforms that can process big amounts of data to learn about actionable steps.
Changes that take minutes on a small site might need months of planning, testing, and deployment in large organizations. Automated solutions and expandable processes become crucial. The core team from development, content, marketing, legal, and product departments must arrange their SEO initiatives together.
When a hybrid model might work better
A hybrid SEO model combines in-house expertise with agency support to give businesses flexibility when their needs change. Companies can keep strategic functions internal while getting help with specialized tasks like technical audits or link building.
The hybrid model lets brands tackle projects that need external expertise, have tight deadlines, or have been waiting too long. To cite an instance, see how Notion built a strong in-house SEO team but still partners with agencies for specialized projects and extra bandwidth.
This cooperative approach works best when everyone understands their responsibilities from the start. The hybrid model ended up offering the best mix: you retain control of strategy while getting specialized expertise as needed.
Making the Final Call: Questions to Ask Yourself
Your final choice between these models depends on your specific situation. Each approach works differently based on what your organization needs and can handle.
Do you have the internal bandwidth?
Take an honest look at your existing resources before you commit to in-house SEO. Managing SEO within your company needs more than just hiring talent. You’ll need smooth cooperation between web developers, content writers, and IT technicians. Poor communication between team members creates most of the avoidable delays in SEO campaigns.
What’s your timeline for results?
Setting realistic expectations helps you choose the right SEO approach. In-house teams need more time to build and show results. Most SEO efforts take 4-12 months to deliver substantial improvements. Agencies can deliver results within 2-3 months because they have 3-year-old systems and processes ready.
How important is flexibility and scale?
Your SEO needs might change over time. Agencies can adjust their service levels quickly when your requirements change. This adaptability becomes valuable especially when you have rapid growth plans or seasonal demands, unlike the fixed capacity of in-house teams.
Do you need niche or general SEO expertise?
Your industry might need specialized knowledge. Niche experts bring focused approaches for specific industries. Yet generalist SEO professionals often deliver better results through their wider experience. Working with clients of all sizes helps them connect patterns between industries and handle different challenges better.
Conclusion
Your choice between building an in-house SEO team or working with an agency depends on your business needs, resources, and goals. We’ve looked at the money involved, how each option works, and what to think about for both approaches.
Most businesses find agencies more cost-effective. A single in-house SEO specialist costs about $138,040 in the first year with all expenses included. Agency services cost around $84,000 per year. Agencies also give you access to experts across different SEO areas without paying full-time employee costs.
In-house teams give you better control. Your team members know your product inside out and can work naturally with other departments. But this control has its limits, especially with tools and technology. Agencies utilize enterprise-level software across many clients, while in-house teams must pay the full cost of these resources.
Time plays a crucial role in this decision. Businesses working with agencies see real results within 3-6 months. Building and training your own team takes 3-6 months before they can even start working on strategy.
Small businesses and startups with tight budgets do better with agency partnerships. Large enterprises with complex needs might want a mixed approach. They can keep strategic control in-house while getting specialized help from outside. Businesses with multiple locations need experts in local SEO – something specialized agencies do really well.
Take an honest look at your internal capacity, time needs, and whether you need specialist knowledge. The best choice changes based on how your organization works, your plans to grow, and what your competition looks like. Whatever path you take, knowing these differences will give you a clear strategy and realistic expectations for success.
Key Takeaways
When deciding between in-house SEO teams and agency partnerships, these essential insights will guide your strategic decision:
- Cost reality check: In-house SEO costs $138,040 first year vs $84,000 for agencies when including salary, benefits, tools, and overhead expenses.
- Expertise access matters: Agencies provide specialized teams across multiple SEO disciplines, while in-house limits you to individual skill sets and knowledge gaps.
- Timeline expectations differ: Agencies deliver results in 3-6 months with established systems, while building in-house teams takes 3-6 months just for hiring and training.
- Tool investment is substantial: Premium SEO tools cost $3,000-$10,000+ annually per platform, but agencies include these in their service packages.
- Business size determines fit: Startups and small businesses benefit from agency partnerships, while enterprises may prefer hybrid models combining both approaches.
The decision ultimately hinges on your budget, timeline, internal bandwidth, and need for specialized expertise. Most businesses find agencies provide better value through shared costs, diverse experience, and faster implementation, while in-house teams offer greater control and product knowledge at significantly higher investment levels.
